Thursday, February 1, 2024

Nicolas Overfield’s Avoidable Tragedy is a Symbolic Failure of Justice

By: Ranier Simons, ADAP Blog Guest Contributor

Access to timely, appropriate care is required for a high quality of life and optimal healthcare outcomes. Vulnerable populations face many challenges to proper care, especially people who are living with HIV (PLWH). Incarcerated PLWH endure compounded harm. The same people who are disproportionately represented in jails and prisons are also disproportionately represented by HIV. Recently reported in the media is the story of a young man, Nicholas Overfield, who lost his life because he was denied his HIV medication while in jail.[1]

Nicholas Overfield is shown with his mother, Lesley Overfield. She is suing El Dorado County and Wellpath Community Care, a company that contracts with governments to provide medical treatment in correctional facilities. (Overfield family)
Photo Source: Los Angeles Times | Overfield family

In February 2022, Nicholas Overfield was arrested and detained at El Dorado County Jail for failure to appear in court.[2] Upon his arrest, he informed the police that he was HIV positive and required his HIV medication daily to keep his HIV controlled.[2] His medication was present at this home, and his mother gave his medication to the police before they took him away.[2] On April 22, 2022, Nicholas’ mother visited him, and he was brought to her in a wheelchair because he was too weak to walk and was unable to speak.[2] The following day, his mother confronted a jail nurse demanding the medical care that he needed, and he subsequently ended up being rushed to the hospital that same night, requiring emergent care. After being hospitalized, he was placed into hospice care and died on June 21, 2022.[2]

Under the Eight Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, prisoners have a right to receive medical care, especially for serious medical issues, regardless of whether they are housed in a local, state, or federal jail or prison.[4] Mandisa Moore-O’Neal, Executive Director of the Center for HIV Law and Policy (CHLP), explains, “It is a fundamental duty to provide the necessary healthcare to those under your care and control, and yet jails and prisons across the country find so many ways to circumvent or all around avoid that duty.” 

It is well-documented that many inmates in jails and prisons receive substandard medical care.[3,5,6]. About 19% of inmates haven’t had a single health-related doctor visit since incarceration. The disjointed and weak infrastructure of incarceration health is especially life-threatening for people with chronic health conditions such as HIV. 

Sign that reads, "Medical neglect is cruel and unusual"
Photo Source: PBS News Hour

Incarcerated PLWH frequently have long delays in receiving medication, spotty administration of medication, or complete omission. This can result in drug resistance, which can make a person even sicker. In the case of Nicolas Overfield, because he was denied his medication, he progressed to AIDS.[2] His lack of proper care in jail also resulted in the failure of his body to fight off the encephalitis varicella-zoster virus that he contracted while incarcerated, which also contributed to his physical decline.[2]

Nicolas Overfield’s situation spotlights one of the contributing factors to poor prison healthcare, which is the outsourcing of prison healthcare to private contractors. Marcus J. Hopkins, founder & executive director of the Appalachian Learning Initiative (AAPLI), explains, “One of the biggest issues with carceral healthcare provision is that most of it occurs behind a wall of secrecy. As with most services, healthcare provision has been contracted out to private companies, such as Corizon and Wellcare, who use trade secrets laws—specifically the provisions that protect the negotiation of services and prices—to shield the exact services they provide.” 

This makes it hard to gather information since they are characteristically lax in reporting their data. A deep-diving Reuters study of over 500 jails revealed that from 2016-2018, jails relying on one of the five leading jail healthcare contractors had higher death rates than facilities where medical services are run by government agencies.[3] Often, some facilities, especially those in smaller jurisdictions with tighter budgets, will hire private contractors for ease of managing health services and to save money.[3]

Unfortunately, the means by which some private contractors save money is by denying care, such as not sending inmates to hospitals when care is needed. The contracts these private providers have sometimes do not have proper standards, staffing requirements, and protocols stipulating protocols for health monitoring and hospitalizations.[3] When inmates, especially those with chronic and mental health conditions, do not receive care, it is not only dangerous for their well-being but also the well-being of other inmates and staff. Inmates with documented mental health issues can be a danger to themselves and others when they are not effectively monitored and kept on their medications. Additionally, when inmates are not treated and screened for sexually transmitted diseases, diseases spread. Eventually, people in jails and prisons are released back into society. This is a danger to public health at large, releasing people with undocumented and uncontrolled diseases or ailments. 

Hand inside prison bars
Photo Source: The Lancet | Copyright © 2016 Sakhorn

The largest jail healthcare companies are Wellpath Holdings Inc., NaphCare Inc., Corizon, PrimeCare Medical Inc., and Armor Correctional Health Services Inc.[3] Wellpath is the company in charge of the jail where Nicolas Overfield was a pre-trial detainee. Not only is Wellpath private, but it is owned by a private equity firm, which would indicate that it has a targeted interest in saving money and making a profit.[3] Some private jail health contractors state that the levels of healthcare challenges of incarcerated populations are why they have higher death rates. However, studies have shown that when you control for the differences in the health of the overall population as compared to the general population, private prisons still have more deaths.[3]

Nicolas Overfield’s avoidable tragedy is a symbolic failure of justice. Ms. Moore-O’Neal expressed, “his incarceration sheds some light on the injustice that is our criminal legal system. The fact that he was even in jail because of a February 2022 arrest for failure to appear in court should have all of us appalled and ready to overhaul this entire system.” Many people like Nicolas Overfield sit in jails and suffer harm and neglect, sometimes fatally before they even make it to trial. Failure to provide constitutionally adequate medical care is not only a legal issue but a human rights issue.

[1] Kandel, J. (2024, January 19). ‘A shocking failure’: Inmate died after jail medical staff denied him HIV medication for months, lawsuit alleges. Retrieved from https://lawandcrime.com/lawsuit/a-shocking-failure-inmate-died-after-jail-medical-staff-denied-him-hiv-medication-for-months-lawsuit-alleges/

[2] Complaint for Damages OVERFIELD v. WELLPATH, et al. (2024, January 16). Retrieved from https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/24369518/overfield-v-wellpath-complaint.pdf

[3] Szep, J., Parker, N., Eisler, P., Smith, G. (2020, October 26). Special Report: U.S. jails are outsourcing medical care — and the death toll is rising. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSL1N2HG0MD/

[4] Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 102 (1976).

[5] Levins, H. (2023, March 6). Reviewing The Flaws of U.S. Prisons and Jails’ Health Care System. Retrieved from https://ldi.upenn.edu/our-work/research-updates/the-flaws-of-u-s-prisons-and-jails-health-care-system/

[6] Wang, L. (2022, June). Chronic Punishment: The unmet health needs of people in state prisons. Retrieved from https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/chronicpunishment.html#insurance

Disclaimer: Guest blogs do not necessarily reflect the views of the ADAP Advocacy Association, but rather they provide a neutral platform whereby the author serves to promote open, honest discussion about public health-related issues and updates.

No comments:

Post a Comment